Trump’s Proposed 10% Rate Cap Sends Credit Card Stocks Reeling as Fintech Alternatives Eye Opportunity
Traditional lenders brace for potential revenue cliff while BNPL platforms and alternative lenders position for market shift.
Wall Street’s banking giants and credit card specialists faced a harsh wake-up call Monday as shares plummeted following President Donald Trump’s weekend proposal to slash credit card interest rates. The plan, which calls for a one-year 10% cap on rates starting January 20, 2026, threatens to dismantle a primary profit engine for the nation’s largest financial institutions. While the traditional banking sector scrambles to assess the damage, a distinct group of alternative lenders and Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) firms are becoming more attractive, potentially gaining a massive competitive edge if the proposal moves forward.
The shockwaves hit the ticker tapes on Monday morning. Shares of Synchrony Financial (NYSE: SYF) and Bread Financial (NYSE: BFH) bore the brunt of the sell-off, with the consumer finance firms slumping 8.4% and 10.7%, respectively. Capital One (NYSE: COF) followed closely, dropping 6.4% as investors weighed the impact on its massive loan portfolio. Even the more premium-focused American Express (NYSE: AXP) shed 4.3%, despite its affluent customer base.
Also Read: Small Digital Health Stock Charts Bold Path to $250 Million Revenue by 2030
Banking Giants Face Steep Earnings Erosion
The proposal strikes at the heart of the full-spectrum lending model. Current Federal Reserve data puts the average credit card interest rate at 22.3%, a significant jump from 16.28% in 2020. Mandating a drop to 10% would essentially halve the interest income for many issuers. Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC) analyst Mike Mayo summarized the industry’s reaction in a succinct note to clients: “Yikes.”
Mayo’s analysis suggests the cap could hit large bank earnings before tax by an estimated 5% to 18%. For lenders that focus exclusively on credit cards, the 10% ceiling could effectively wipe out earnings altogether. This reality weighed on the big three commercial banks. Citigroup (NYSE: C) tumbled 3%, JPMorgan Chase (NYSE: JPM) fell 1.4%, and Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) dropped 1.1%. Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS), which recently transitioned its Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) Card portfolio to JPMorgan, also finds itself navigating a suddenly treacherous regulatory landscape.
“They really abused the credit cards,” Trump told reporters on Air Force One. He added that if lenders do not comply by the deadline, “then they’re in violation of the law.”
Source: Reuters YouTube
Rise of the Alternative Lender
While the old guard of finance retreats, fintech innovators are finding a silver lining. Affirm Holdings (NASDAQ: AFRM) saw its stock jump as much as 2.9% in early trading as investors realized that a 10% cap on traditional cards could push millions of consumers toward installment-based loans. However, AFRM was unable to hold its gains, eventually closing the day down 6.6%.
Mizuho analyst Dan Dolev highlighted this shift, noting:
“President Trump’s tweet on Truth Social demanding a one-year 10% cap on credit card interest rates could have major positive ramifications for BNPL and personal loan providers like AFRM, UPST, SOFI, XYZ & PYPL.”
As banks tighten their belts, they will likely raise the bar for who gets a credit card. If a bank cannot charge a rate that justifies the risk of lending to a subprime borrower, it will likely close the account or slash the credit limit. This creates a vacuum that companies like Upstart Holdings (NASDAQ: UPST), SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ: SOFI), and PayPal (NASDAQ: PYPL) are eager to fill. These platforms often utilize alternative data to assess risk, allowing them to offer personal loans or installment plans that might remain viable even under new rate structures.
Other potential beneficiaries include Block (NYSE: XYZ) and Atlanticus Holdings (NASDAQ: ATLC), which provide credit solutions to consumers often overlooked by major banks. By operating outside the traditional revolving credit card model, these firms might avoid the direct sting of the 10% cap while capturing a displaced customer base.
Also Read: Why Big Investors Who Can’t Buy Crypto Are Gobbling Up These Stocks Instead
Legislative Hurdles and Economic Blowback
Despite the market’s visceral reaction, many analysts remain skeptical that a 10% cap will ever see the light of day. Implementing such a cap would likely require an Act of Congress, as the National Bank Act currently grants banks the authority to charge rates based on the laws of their home states.
“It would take an Act of Congress for such rate caps to be in place, given the overwhelming legal challenges an executive order would likely face,” wrote analysts at UBS Global.
The banking industry is already mounting a defense. Five major trade groups warned that such a move would be “devastating for millions of American families and small business owners.” They argue that a 10% cap would not help the poor, but rather force them toward “less regulated, more costly alternatives” like pawn shops.
Even payment giants like Visa (NYSE: V) and Mastercard (NYSE: MA) saw their shares slip nearly 2%, though they do not lend directly. The fear is that a massive reduction in credit availability would stifle consumer spending, slowing the transaction volumes that drive their revenue. Across the pond, British lenders like Barclays (NYSE: BCS) also felt the heat, hitting one-month lows as the global financial community watched the U.S. policy shift with bated breath.
A Turning Point for Financial Strategy
As the fourth-quarter earnings season begins, all eyes turn to bank executives for a roadmap through this uncertainty. The industry has historically proven resilient to regulatory shifts, but the sheer scale of a 10% cap represents an existential threat to the current credit card business model.
In a joint statement, the trade groups wrote:
“Evidence shows that a 10% interest rate cap would reduce credit availability and be devastating for millions of American families and small business owners who rely on and value their credit cards.”
Whether the proposal is a serious policy shift or a tactical negotiation piece, it has already succeeded in resetting the market’s expectations. For now, the momentum has shifted toward the agile fintech players, leaving traditional titans to defend their most profitable products against a populist tide.
Small Cap News Movers & Winner Deep Dive – By WealthyVC.com
We scan over 10,000 publicly listed stocks across all seven North American exchanges to uncover the market-moving news that actually matters—focusing on high-quality, liquid, growth-oriented companies in sectors attracting serious capital, like AI, blockchain, biotech, and consumer tech.
Each week, we publish Small Cap News Movers, a curated roundup of small and micro-cap stocks surging on meaningful catalysts. We break down what’s driving the move, tap into rumors swirling on social media, and surface sharp insights from both industry experts and retail sleuths.
From this list, we select one standout stock for our Small Cap Winner Deep Dive, released the next day, where we take a closer look at the fundamentals, narrative, and technicals that suggest this winner could keep running.
Powered by our proprietary 4-element, AI-driven analysis system, our goal is simple: cut through the noise, remove the emotion, and help investors dominate the small-cap market with momentum-driven strategies—completely free.
Sign up for email alerts to get the moves before our social media followers.
Read Next: Why Nvidia’s Tech Investments Could Transform the Entire AI Innovation Ecosystem
Join the Discussion in the WVC Facebook Investor Group
Do you have a stock tip or news story suggestion? Please email us at: invest@wealthyvc.com.
Disclaimer: Wealthy VC does not hold a position in any of the stocks, ETFs or cryptocurrencies mentioned in this article.
